Theatre Review: ‘West Side Story’

at Children’s Theatre of Annapolis

Posted By: Julia Tucker on: October 28, 2025

 

“The air is humming,” and something great has come to the Children’s Theatre of Annapolis (CTA) stage! An extraordinarily talented cast of young performers is currently staging “West Side Story,” arguably one of the most challenging shows in musical theater. The troupe triumphantly delivers on this feat, demonstrating remarkable stamina and skill. Splendidly directed by Michelle Bruno, this production is an impressive presentation of Leonard Bernstein and Stephen Sondheim’s celebrated masterpiece.

 

Based on Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet,” “West Side Story” revolves around two rival teenage street gangs in 1950s New York City. The American Jets and Puerto Rican Sharks have relentless hatred for one another, and this clash leads to raging conflict and escalating violence. At a town dance, Maria (from the Sharks) and Tony (from the Jets) meet and fall in love. Because they each come from different groups, their romance is forbidden, and this budding relationship creates much contention. Amid the continuing animosity between the Jets and the Sharks, the teens witness murder and social unrest, leading to a tragic culmination.

 

As Maria and Tony, Leila Bennett and Jeremiah Gilbert each gave superb performances. Their chemistry was enchanting, and their gorgeous voices blended beautifully on their duets. Gilbert’s tender rendition of “Maria” showcased his mellow, tenor voice, and he grippingly expressed every emotion from elation to heartache. Bennett’s soaring soprano was on full display in “I Feel Pretty,” and she brilliantly maintained a convincing accent when delivering her lines. She movingly illustrated the winding path of the bond between Maria and Tony, effectively conveying both apprehension and devotion.

Amaya Shannon was spectacular as Maria’s mentor and confidante, Anita. She exhibited magnificent vocal talent in “A Boy Like That” and “I Have a Love.” Her dynamic stage presence dazzled the audience, demonstrating phenomenal dance technique and radiating grace and enthusiasm. The effervescent Caylee Rogers was wonderful as Anita’s best friend, Rosalia. Rogers’ resounding voice was featured in her duet with Shannon in “America,” and her animated facial expressions were delightful. In a standout performance as, Riff, the leader of the Jets, leader, Liam Cool brilliantly personified this character with bravado, displaying smooth vocals as a featured soloist in “Jet Song” and “Cool.” Israel Gilbert, as Bernardo, the Sharks’ leader (and Maria’s older brother) presented a rich baritone, and his protective behavior toward Maria was heartwarming. “Somewhere” soloist, Madelyn Luebbers, delivered a stirring rendition of this iconic number, and her vocals perfectly conveyed the song’s moving message.

 

Music Director LeVar Betts led the cast through the notoriously complex score, which was exquisitely played by his 11-piece orchestra. Betts’ expert leadership was reflected in the cast’s ability to flawlessly execute these difficult pieces. Katie Sheldon’s intricate choreography (based on original work by Jerome Robbins) featured a vast range of styles, from the haunting ballet in “Somewhere” to the lively acrobatics in “Gee, Officer Krupke.” Atticus Cooper Boidy’s striking set design vividly depicted the tone of each setting, from the bleak New York City streets filled with grime to the vibrant neighborhood drugstore decked in 1950s decor.

 

“West Side Story” at the Children’s Theatre of Annapolis is a poignant expression of artistry and sentiment that is a must-see experience. Nearly 70 years after its debut, the core themes that this play explores still resonate today. CTA has staged an outstanding kickoff for its 2025-2026 season, and audiences are guaranteed an astoundingly entertaining presentation.

 

Running Time: Approximately two hours and 30 minutes, including a 15-minute intermission.

Advisory: Recommended for audiences ages 12+. Parental guidance is suggested (mature themes, violence, language, themes of social injustice).

 

“West Side Story” runs through November 9, 2025 at the Children’s Theatre of Annapolis, 1661 Bay Head Road, Annapolis, MD 21409. Performances are Fridays at 7:00 p.m., Saturdays at 11 a.m. and 4 p.m., and Sundays at 2 p.m. (there is no performance on Friday, October 31). For more information and to purchase tickets, go online or visit the box office prior to the performance.

 

SOURCE: https://mdtheatreguide.com/2025/10/theatre-review-west-side-story-at-childrens-theatre-of-annapolis/